Back to Blogs

Navigating the Perilous Waters of Ballet Company Contracts

Robert Fulton - April 5, 2024, 12:31 a.m.

The world of professional ballet is as precarious as it is enchanting, with dancers often finding themselves in vulnerable positions when it comes to contract negotiations. A disturbing trend that has surfaced in discussions is the revocation of written contract offers by ballet companies—a scenario that, while rare, has occurred and raises numerous legal and ethical questions.

When a dancer receives a contract offer, it's a moment filled with joy and the promise of future achievements. However, the legal intricacies of these contracts can turn dreams into nightmares. The basic principle of contract law states that once an offer is extended and accepted within the designated period, it becomes binding, unless there's a failure on the dancer's part. Yet, the ballet world operates on the fringe of traditional labor laws, making these situations complex.

The matter becomes even murkier with contracts for second company positions or those not counter-signed by the artistic director. The expectation is often that the dancer would not enforce the contract, leading to a precarious situation for those who've dedicated their lives to this art form. Regardless, the type of contract—whether for a primary company or a second company—should not affect its enforceability, assuming specified compensation and mutual agreement.

The ethical implications are profound. Ballet companies, struggling financially, might find themselves forced to retract offers, leaving dancers in a lurch. But what recourse does a dancer have? Legal action could ensure, but the ballet community's tight-knit nature and the potential for burning bridges make this a daunting path. Moreover, the financial feasibility of fighting for what might be a modest wage at best is questionable.

In such a scenario, the dancer faces a daunting decision: fight a potentially pyrrhic battle or move on and seek other opportunities. This is a heart-wrenching situation for someone who has invested countless hours and immense effort into their craft.

The ballet industry needs more transparent and fair practices when it comes to contracts. Dancers deserve protection and clarity regarding their employment status. As discussions continue, one thing is clear: the need for a systemic overhaul to ensure dancers are not left vulnerable to the whims of companies.

For those navigating this challenging landscape, it's crucial to meticulously review contract terms, seek legal advice if possible, and consider the broader implications of the agreements they enter into. The dream of dancing professionally is a noble pursuit, but it should not come at the cost of one's rights and dignity.

In the end, this issue underscores the broader challenges facing the world of professional ballet—a world that, for all its beauty on stage, involves complex, often harsh realities behind the curtains.